Huwebes, Agosto 16, 2012

Water Refilling Station


Sa isang siyudad sa Pangasinan, maraming naglipanang water refilling station.  Mas marami pa ang kanilang bilang sa bilang ng barangay sa nasabing lungsod.  Mahigit kalahati sa kanilang bilang ang walang kaukulang permit mula sa Department of Health para magpatakbo ng isang water refilling station.  Wala rin silang business permit mula sa Business Permit and License Office ng lungsod.

Tumigil bumili ng tubig sa isang water refilling station ang pamilya ni Aling Sebya dahil sumakit ang tiyan ng mga bata kapag umiinom nito.  Kanyang napag-alaman na wala palang Mayor’s Permit ang nasabing water refilling station.

Tanong:
Sino ang maaaring kasuhan ni Aling Sebya sa pagkakasakit ng tiyan ng kanyang mga anak?

Sagot:
Ang mga maaaring kasuhan ni Aling Sebya ay ang sumusunod:  ang water refilling station, ang City Health Office at ang Business Permit and License Office.

Ang water refilling station ay mananagot dahil sa kagustuhang kumita, siya ay nagbenta ng tubig na dahilan ng sakit ng kanyang mga customer at kahit wala siyang kaukulang mga dokumento para sa nasabing bisnis.

Ang City Health Office at Business Permit and License Office ay maaaring kasuhan dahil sa pagpapabaya sa tungkulin.  Hindi dapat hinayaan ng City Health Office at Business Permit and License Office na magbukas at magbenta ng tubig ang nasabing water refilling station kung ito ay hindi pa nainspection ng City Health Office na hindi kontiminado ang tubig na ibinibenta.  Meron ding pagpapabaya ang Business Permit and License Office dahil hinayaang magbukas at magbenta ang nasabing water refilling station kahit wala pa itong Mayor’s Permit mula sa kanila.

Miyerkules, Agosto 15, 2012

Lascivious conduct through fraudulent machination


QUESTION: “A” is married to “X”. “Z” pretended to be his twin brother, “X”, and by that ploy he was able to freely undress “A”, kiss her nipples and rub his erect penis on the mons pubis of her vulva. After a few minutes, “Z” ejaculated. The crime committed is

(A) Rape since under RA No. 8353 this crime can be committed by means of fraudulent machination.
(B) Attempted rape because there is intent to have sexual intercourse on the part of “Z”. 
(C) Acts of lasciviousness because “Z” committed lascivious conduct upon “A” without intent to have sexual intercourse.
(D) Unjust vexation because “Z” did not employ violence or intimation, and hence, he could not be held liable for acts of lasciviousness.

While it is true that pretending to be a husband of the victim constitutes fraudulent machination, which is a mode of committing rape under RA No. 8353, nevertheless “Z” cannot be held liable for consummated rape. Jurisprudence dictates that the labia majora must be entered for rape to be consummated, and not merely for the penis to stroke the surface of the female organ.  Thus, a grazing of the surface of the female organ or touching the mons pubis of the pudendum is not sufficient to constitute consummated rape. Absent any showing of the slightest penetration of the female organ, i.e., touching of labia majora or minora of the pudendum by the penis, there can be no consummated rape (People vs. Campuhan, G.R. No. 129433, March 30, 2000, En Banc). Hence, “A” is not the answer.

“Z” cannot be held liable for attempted rape since he did not cause his erect penis to enter the labia of “A” in the midst of opportunity thereof. This indicates lack of intent to have sexual intercourse, which is an indispensable element of attempted rape (People vs. Abanilla, G.R. Nos. 148673-75, October 17, 2003). Hence, “B” is not the answer.

Under Article 336 of the Revised Penal Code, any person who shall commit any act of lasciviousness upon other persons of either sex, under any of the circumstances mentioned in the preceding article, shall be punished by prision correccional. Article 335, which is the preceding article of Article 336, is the definitional provision of rape. Hence, the modes of committing rape such as use of force or intimidation are the same as those of committing acts of lasciviousness.

RA No. 8353 reclassified rape as crime against persons and made it punishable under Article 266-A of the Revised Penal Code. Under this provision, fraudulent machination is a new mode of committing rape. However, since this new mode is not found under Article 335 of the Code, it cannot be treated as mode of committing acts of lasciviousness. The terms “the preceding article” mentioned in Article 336 still pertains to Article 335 and not Article 266-A. 

In Flordeliz vs. People, G.R. No. 186441, March 3, 2010 - The crime of Acts of Lasciviousness has the following elements: (1) That the offender commits any act of lasciviousness or lewdness; (2) That it is done under any of the following circumstances: a. By using force or intimidation; or b. When the offended party is deprived of reason or otherwise unconscious; or c. When the offended party is under 12 years of age; and (3) That the offended party is another person of either sex.

In this case, “Z” committed lascivious conduct upon “A” by means of fraudulent machination and not by using force or intimidation. Hence, “Z” cannot be held liable for acts of lasciviousness. Without employing force or intimidation, acts of lewdness constitute the crime of unjust vexation (See: People vs. Bernaldo, CA-G.R. No. 26102-R, Oct. 31, 1959). Hence, the answer is “D” and not “C”.

Marlo Campanilla
Presiding Judge
Metropolitan Trial Court
Branch 83, Caloocan City

Martes, Agosto 14, 2012

SEC-OGC Opinion No. 12-05 dated April 2, 2012


TJM Association is a non-stock national organization with several chapters nationwide.  Based on its By-Laws, it has 25 National Directors consisting of 21 Regional Directors and 4 Sectoral Directors.  The 21 Regional Directors are elected by members belonging to defined geographical areas while Sectoral Directors are elected nationwide by members belonging to each sector.

The SEC was asked to opine on whether TJM’s method of electing directors on a regional basis is in violation of the Corporation Code?

Section 89 of the Corporation Code, applicable to non-stock corporations, provides that the right of members to vote may be limited to the extent specified in the articles and by-laws.  Under this provision, there is nothing objectionable about the manner of voting for the directors of TJM as provided in its By-Laws. Its By-Laws have in effect limited the right of members to vote only for candidates for director for their own region.  Hence, under Section 89, regional elections for directors may be allowed as long as it is the mode of election provided in the non-stock corporation’s by-laws.

Lunes, Agosto 13, 2012

BIR Ruling No. 247-12 dated April 13, 2012


JMM Co. is a domestic corporation operating toll facilities by virtue of a franchise.  It held in trust for the Government certain shares in various subsidiaries and joint venture companies.  In view of the expiration of its franchise in 1997, P Co. was ordered by the Supreme Court to transfer the said shares in favor of the Government.

Being made without monetary consideration and merely for confirmation of title / ownership in favor of the Government as beneficial owner, the BIR held that transfer is not subject to Capital Gains Tax imposed under Section 27(A) and (D)(2) of the Tax Code.  Likewise, the BIR opined that no donor’s tax is applicable since the transaction was made without intent to do an act of liberality on the part of the transferor and merely in compliance with a Supreme Court decision.  Further, the transfer is subject to the DST on certificates under Section 188 of the Tax Code, not to the DST on sales, or agreements to sell, or transfer of shares or certificates of stock.

Accounting Times, Vol. 62 No. 4, June 2012

Biyernes, Agosto 10, 2012

Psychological incapacity


Dahil si Sarah ay buntis na, sila ni Gerard ay ikinasal sa bahay ng magulang ni Sarah ng isang pastor na protestante. Meron silang tig-tatlong ninong at ninang na dumalo sa nasabing kasalan.

Pagkatapos ng kasal, madalas sinasaktan ni Gerard si Sarah lalo na kung lasing kung umuwi galing sa trabaho.  Dahil ang inatupag ay ang pagbabarkada, hindi nagkaroon ng permanenteng trabaho si Gerard.  Tiniis ni Sarah ang ganitong sitwasyon para sa kapakanan ng kanilang dalawang anak.

Minsang umuwing lasing si Gerard, nag-away sila ni Sarah na noon ay buntis sa pangatlo nilang anak at sinakal ni Gerard ang kanilang pangalawang anak na isang taong gulang.  Habang hawak ang leeg ng bata, sinabi ni Gerard na pabigat sila na buhay niya.

Hindi na makatiis si Sarah at gusto na niyang hiwalayan si Gerard.

Tanong:
Kung magsampa ng kasong annulment of marriage ayon sa Article 36 ng Family Code si Sarah, makakuha kaya siya ng favorableng desisyon?

Sagot:
Kung maliban sa salaysay ni Sarah ay matunayan ng hukuman na taglay ni Gerard ang walang kakayanan na gampanan ang papel bilang asawang lalaki dahil sa isang depekto sa pagkatao na pinatunayan ng isang psychologist, ang kasalang Sarah at Gerard ay maaaring mapawalang bisa.

Mandatory submission of quarter Summary List of Sales and Purchases


On February 20, 2012, the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) issued Revenue Regulations No. (RR) 1-2012, which requires the mandatory submission of quarterly summary list of sales and purchases (SLSP) by all Value-Added Tax (VAT) registered taxpayers, thereby amending Section 4.114-3 of RR 16 -2005, as amended, otherwise known as the Consolidated Value-Added Tax Regulations of 2005.

SECTION 4.114-3 (a). Submission of Quarterly Summary List of Sales and Purchases is modified as follows:

1. Persons required to submit summary lists of sales – All persons liable for VAT such as manufacturers, wholesalers, service-providers, among others are required to submit Summary List of Sales.

2. Persons required to submit summary lists of purchases - All persons liable for VAT such as manufacturers, service-providers, among others are required to file Summary List of Purchases.

Moreover, Section 4.114-3(e) 7 has also been modified to provide that the quarterly SLSP shall be submitted through compact disk-recordable (CDR) medium following the format provided in Subsection (g) of the regulations.

All reference to “magnetic form 3.5-inch floppy diskettes” in RR 16-2005 shall henceforth refer to “Compact Disk-Recordable (CDR)” device.

This Revenue Regulations took effect on January 1, 2012.

Outsourcing Brief – January to March 2012
Punongbayan and Araullo

Miyerkules, Agosto 8, 2012

Certificate of Authority to Register


Si Ramona ay bumili ng lupa kay Jonas sa halagang P500,000 upang pagtitirikan ng bahay.  Si Ramona ang naglakad sa papeles para ilipat sa kanyang pangalan ang mga dokumento ng lupain.  Nakakuha ng Tax Declaration si Ramona mula sa Provincial Assessor.

Nagtataka si Filipina kung bakit naibenta ang nasabing lupa habang ito ay isinanla sa kanya ni Jonas sa halagang P60,000.  Kaya humingi siya ng kopya ng Deed of Sale mula sa Municipal Assessor at kanyang napag-alaman na hindi pala nagbayad ng kaukulang Capital Gains Tax si Ramona dahil walang Certificate of Authority to Register mula sa Bureau of Internal Revenue.  Ganoong din hindi nakansela ang Titulo ng nasabing lupain mula kay Jason papunta kay Romana dahil hindi rin dumaan sa Register of Deeds ang transaksyon.

Mga Tanong:
(a)      Sino-sino ang mga mananagot sa pagkalipat ng Tax Declaration sa pangalan ni Ramona na hindi dumaan sa BIR at Register of Deeds?

(b)      Ano ang dapat gawin ni Filipina upang mapangalagaan ang kanyang interes sa lupang isinanla sa kanya na lumalabas na ibinenta pagkatapos kay Ramona?

Mga Sagot:
(a)      Kung walang kinalaman ang BIR at SEC sa pagkalipat ng Tax Declaration sa pangalan ni Ramona ang mga taong mananagot ay ang nakinabang sa paglipat ng pangalan na hindi dumaan sa tamang proseso at ang tanggapan ng gobyerno na hindi humingi ng mga kailangan dokumento sa paglilipat sa pangalan sa Tax Declaration.

Kung susundin ang daan matuwid sa paglilipat ng pangalan ng bumili sa Tax Declaration bilang bagong may-ari, hihingin ng Municipal o Provincial Assessor ang Certificate of Authority to Register galing sa Bureau of Internal Revenue. Ito ay patunay na nabayaran ang Capital Gains Tax at Documentary Stamp Tax sa bentahan ng lupa.  Pangalawa, hihingin din ng Municipal or Provincial Assessor ang Certificate of Registration mula sa Register of Deeds. Ito naman ay patunay na ang transaksyon ay dumaan sa Register of Deeds.  Pangatlo, hihingin pa rin ng Municipal o Provincial Assessor ang Tax Clearance Certificate mula sa Municipal Treasurer bilang patunay na bayad hanggang sa kasalukuyan ang Real Property Taxes ang naturang lupain.

(b)      Ang dapat gawin ni Filipina ay magsampa ng kaukulang kaso laban kay Jason sa pagbebenta ng lupang dati ng nakasanla at hilingin sa Register of Deeds na i-annotate sa titulo ang kontrata ng sanla sa pagitan niya at ng dating may-ari.

This article is also published at:
http://www.placesure.com/groups/general-public/forums/topic/certificate-of-authority-to-register/